While the details of last Friday’s tragic death of George Desdunes ’13 are still unclear, MetaEzra has published a thought-provoking post on the big picture issues of this incident. All of his speculations are likely to be big points of discussion in the coming weeks and months:
– Imagine that instead of Desdunes’s untimely death, he only was hospitalized. Would the fraternity still have been suspended for violation of University alcohol policy?
– Imagine that nothing afoul would have come out of SAE this past weekend. Would it still have been suspended for (pretty much assumed) violation of the University’s alcohol policy?
– Imagine that instead of letting the Greek system persist through the 50s and 60s, Cornell would have decommissioned the entire system like many other colleges did during that time (e.g.Williams) and instead developed small, co-educational living-leaning houses and co-ops. Would Desdunes still have died?
– Or alternatively, imagine that Cornell had developed a residential college experience for all underclassmen (freshman and sophomores) as part of Rawlings’s residential initiative, banning Greek system involvement until later on in a student’s academic career (much like Dartmouth). Would Desdunes still have died?
I’m not trying to point fingers, but it’s something to think about. Institutions matter. Culture matters. The environment we create for ourselves matters. And clearly we are all in some way responsible.
Today the Diplomacist blog debuted a new feature, Partisan Response, which provides contrasting partisan commentary on international affairs issues from the Review and Progressive.
Here’s Executive Editor Joe Bonica’s response to the article titled “The Reality of Cuba’s Reforms”:
Though President Raúl Castro has acted on behalf of his Fidel brother to “liberalize” the economy by reducing Cuban state employment and allowing limited entrepreneurship, much more needs to be done to truly facilitate this transition, including allowing free access to information. Unfortunately, the Castro regime has a terrible history of real reform.
The position of the United States should therefore be one that is firm but non-interventionist at the same time, being especially steadfast in the need for information to flow freely in the country. Cuba is off to a fairly good start with its current liberalization reforms; the United States should encourage continued liberalization of the economy as the best engine to lift Cuba out of its terrible doldrums.
However, the United States should also inform the Castro government that a liberal economy functions best when full information is available to the purchasing public. It would also be hugely positive for the Cuban economy to allow free trade in the region. Perhaps, then, a deal could be worked out between the U.S and Cuba: if Cuba promises to vastly increase the flow of information to their own citizens, then the United States will either greatly modify or completely eliminate the decades-old embargo on the country. Whether or not this realpolitik will work waits to be seen, but if the Castros truly intend a liberalized Cuban economy, this will prove a very telling test.
Last year’s standout senior goalie Ben Scrivens backed up Toronto starter James Reimer on Saturday night against Ottawa. Scrivens’ quick ascent up the Toronto depth chart- helped along the way by an injury to J-S Giguere and poor play by Jonas Gustavsson- makes him the second Big Red alumnus to get a call up this year. Given the tremendous odds he has already overcome to get to the Toronto bench, don’t count him out in terms of making an NHL start this season.
Correction: Scrivens would be the third Big Red alumnus called up this year- Brendon Nash made his debut with Montreal last week. Thanks to MA for the catch.
Just 12 hours after the Sun leaked the news that Nelly would be this year’s Slope Day performer, the Cornell Insider has learned from a source close to the situation that Lupe Fiasco is scheduled to perform on April 17 in Barton Hall. His website corroborates the report. The question is: why does the concert commission have such better success than the Slope Day committee (in our humble opinion)? Lupe, a rapper of similar vein as Kid Cudi, who performed this past fall, has experienced a resurgence in popularity recently with his single ‘Show Goes On.’
A couple of weeks ago the Columbia Spectator reported on a leaked university document that revealed that at least 1 in 12 Columbia undergrads earned at least a 4.0 last semester:
The spreadsheet listed 482 students in Columbia College and the School of Engineering and Applied Science who earned perfect grade point averages. Whether the numbers reflect grade inflation, the criticism often aimed at universities giving higher grades than in years past, remains unclear.
Stuart Rojstaczer, a retired Duke professor who has written widely on grade inflation, said that since the data only includes students with a 4.0 or higher, the numbers were difficult to compare specifically to other schools.
As readers of this blog know, we’ve covered the Cornell grade inflation debate extensively over the past year.. here, here, and here. Rojstaczer is right, though- even the 1 in 12 figure is difficult to use in a comparison of grade inflation levels between schools. Cornell inducts the top 3% of A&S juniors into Phi Beta Kappa, all of whom had above a 4.0 GPA last year. The threshold for graduating in the top 10% of A&S is 3.92, so at least it’s pretty safe to say that fewer than 8% of Cornellians graduate with above 4.0′s.
That’s how UVA Professor Jonathan Haidt described the grand total of 3 self-identified conservatives at a 1,000 person social psychology conference. From the NYT article:
“This is a statistically impossible lack of diversity,” Dr. Haidt concluded, noting polls showing that 40 percent of Americans are conservative and 20 percent are liberal. In his speech and in an interview, Dr. Haidt argued that social psychologists are a “tribal-moral community” united by “sacred values” that hinder research and damage their credibility — and blind them to the hostile climate they’ve created for non-liberals.
“Anywhere in the world that social psychologists see women or minorities underrepresented by a factor of two or three, our minds jump to discrimination as the explanation,” said Dr. Haidt, who called himself a longtime liberal turned centrist. “But when we find out that conservatives are underrepresented among us by a factor of more than 100, suddenly everyone finds it quite easy to generate alternate explanations.”
In his speech, Dr. Haidt also revealed email correspondences from non-liberal graduate students who discussed the pressures and biases they felt from their liberal colleagues. One email read:
“I consider myself very middle-of-the-road politically: a social liberal but fiscal conservative. Nonetheless, I avoid the topic of politics around work… Given what I’ve read of the literature, I am certain any research I conducted in political psychology would provide contrary findings and, therefore, go unpublished. Although I think I could make a substantial contribution to the knowledge base, and would be excited to do so, I will not.”
The Cornell Review devotes many of its pages to reporting the harmful effects of liberal bias on campus, among students and with professors in the classroom. As any Cornell conservative- or for that matter, open-minded liberal- knows, a liberally-biased professor takes away from an enriching learning environment. Alternative historical perspectives are often not discussed, pro-market arguments are overlooked, and conservative political figures are treated with scorn and ridicule. But Haidt believes that the negative consequences of a liberal academe extend far beyond the classroom. Take, for example, the tens of millions of dollars that universities spend on research and diversity programs based on the assumption that women face systematic bias and discrimination in the academic workplace. Research contradicting this assumption, like a recent study by Cornell Psychology Profesors Stephen J. Ceci and Wendy M. Williams, is ignored, and universities continue to invest valuable dollars into misguided efforts:
“Thus,” [the Cornell researchers] conclude, “the ongoing focus on sex discrimination in reviewing, interviewing and hiring represents costly, misplaced effort. Society is engaged in the present in solving problems of the past.” Instead of presuming discrimination in science or expecting the sexes to show equal interest in every discipline, the Cornell researchers say, universities should make it easier for women in any field to combine scholarship with family responsibilities.
Perhaps equally outspoken academics like Dr. Haidt can continue to bring attention to and eventually mend- or at least ameliorate- the problem of underrepresented conservatives in academia.
No, not the Mark Kirk ’81 kind. Earlier today MetaEzra first picked up on Colin Greening’s recent call up to the Ottawa Senators. Greening has spent the beginning of the season playing for the minor league Binghamton Senator of the AHL. From Ottawa’s website:
It wasn’t exactly what the Cornell University grad had in mind when he and his girlfriend, Tissy, arrived in Chicago to spend the AHL all-star break. They’d barely landed in the Windy City when Greening got the call to head to Ottawa.
“She was saying to me ‘where do you want to go to eat in Chicago first?’ and then I’m getting this call,” said Greening in recalling the frenzied events of Sunday afternoon. “So I had to tell her ‘I don’t think I going to be able to do that anymore.’ It was just a lot of surprise. She was happy for me, but it was kind of a whirlwind. I had to get back here and get all my gear and things like that. It was an exciting time, to say the least.”
Greening had 8 minutes of ice during the game- not bad at all for a rookie call-up in his first NHL start. This appearance makes Greening the first 2010 Cornell Hockey senior to get a big league start. While it’s not clear how long he will stay with Ottawa- he’s not on the roster for tonight’s shootout against Detroit- the call up is already a significant accomplishment. Who’s next? Nash or Nash?
And finally allows peer institutions access to its enormous library collection. From the Cornell Chronicle:
Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) have joined Borrow Direct, the rapid book request and delivery system that enables Cornell library users to get materials quickly from a network of partners. Their regularly circulating materials will be added to the combined catalog, bringing the total to more than 70 million.
I remember that on my visit to Cornell, back in 2006, Harvard’s refusal to share was a major source of chuckles for my tour group.
[UPDATE] with information from Cornell Study Abroad.
There are currently 17 Cornell students studying in the North Africa and Mid East region, in Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Israel, Morocco, and Turkey. The one student currently studying in Egypt through Middlebury College’s program is scheduled to leave soon, but specific dates were not given. Israel is the only country under a U.S. State Department Travel Warning, and Cornell has not instructed students to return from any of these locations, according to Study Abroad director Richard Gaulton.
“The last time I remember Cornell withdrawing students being from a country was in 2008 when a group of students volunteering in Kenya was brought out of that country due to serious post-election violence,” he told The Review in an email tonight. “It is sound safety advice to tell students to avoid protests and demonstrations,” he added.
Dozens of Cornell students are just beginning their semester abroad programs as protests continue to spread throughout the Middle East. Cornellians studying in Egypt undoubtedly find themselves in the most precarious situation- protests have turned violent in several major cities and telephone and internet communications are not available.
Robert Morrissey ’12 spoke with The Review about the situation in Amman, Jordan, as well as the status of other Cornell students in the region:
The protests in the region have affected class discussions and provided excellent material for our class studying Arabic language used in the media, but have yet to affect daily life in Amman. Munther Younes (the coordinator of the program and coordinator of NES’ Arabic program) has told me he is following developments closely, but fully does not expect the situation in Jordan to deteriorate. At this point the approach Cornell is taking with the IAP (Intensive Arabic Program) is that “we’ll cross the bridge when we come to it” should unrest in Jordan grow. In terms of Cornell students studying in Egypt (I am unaware of any who planned to study in Tunisia), one student who planned to study in Cairo had her program canceled when the situation deteriorated before she left the United States. Another Cornell student has been studying in Alexandria since January 8 through Middlebury College’s “School in the Middle East” Arabic Program. Middlebury is hoping to get its students out tomorrow and I expect that will mean returning to Cornell.
Morrissey is participating in a Cornell-run program with other Cornell students in Amman, Jordan. He has more excellent coverage of the protests here. Below is a video from his YouTube account, filmed in Amman, Jordan yesterday.
Jordanians are more confident in their government, Morrissey says on his website. “While protests continue, they have yet to exceed 5,000 people in a capital city of two million people and have remained exceedingly civil,” he says.
We are still awaiting an official university statement on the situation. More updates to come.
Check out the recently released fraternity and sorority grade reports. When comparing the average house GPAs between the spring and fall semesters, one unusual trend sticks out: GPAs were actually higher during the spring semester than the fall semester. For sororities the differences was .08 (3.317 vs 3.237) and fraternities had a positive gap of .086 (3.247 vs 3.161). While it’s not clear whether these differences are statistically significant (even without estimating standard errors, my guess is that they are), it’s still surprising that GPAs were not significantly lower during the pledging-intensive spring semester. Any guesses as to why?
[UPDATE]: For some reason the grade report PDFs are no longer available on Cornell’s website. Above are the originally reported, correct figures.