Cornell Insider

Stay Informed. Demand truth. Be an Insider. – A blog by the writers of the Cornell Review

Posts Tagged ‘Cornell suicide’

Cornell Top Stories of 2010 – #2: (Suicide) Fences

Posted by Oliver Renick on January 1, 2011

Much has been said of the suicides of 2010. Nevertheless, their impact on students and campus culture makes the topic of suicide the second biggest story of 2010. To grasp the relevance of this subject just take a look at the ‘tag cloud’ to your right. 31 posts tagged with ‘Cornell suicide’ make the topic one of the most talked about on this website. After the string of tragedies in the Spring of 2010, University officials erected temporary fences. These bridge barriers have since provided unending debates and speculation on their effectiveness.

To see all the articles relating to: Cornell suicide and the fences (click).

A month after Bradley Ginsburg’s body was found in the Fall Creek Gorge below Thurston Bridge, Matthew Zika’s and William Sinclair’s bodies were found within the same 24 hours. All three were determined to be suicides.

In late March, the administration announced it would install fences along Cornell’s bridges. When students arrived back to campus after Spring Break, floppy and cheap chain link fences lined the walkways. Backlash from students erupted quickly. A little sensationalism lead the way.

A lot of efforts were made to combat the fences in their early form. Students tagged them with graffiti, planted ‘Ithaca is Fences’ stickers on the links, put smiley faces on them, and eventually resorted to painting them in rainbows of colors to help make them appear hospitable. Cornell’s ‘Caring Community’ website was designed to inform students, professors, and parents on mental health efforts on campus and to serve as a forum for updates on student life and death. Right now, the Caring Community website promotes events like guided bird walk tours, and zen meditation practice.

Ithaca Common Council voted unanimously in June to extend the temporary fences another ten weeks. Over the summer, the fences took on a more professional, less cage-like, albeit more permanent form. The chain links were done away with and slightly more aesthetically pleasing metal bars were built. But that’s not to say the argument subsided. When more stickers began appearing again this fall, Deirdre Mulligan ’11 voiced a seldom-heard position on the fences.

Though many students kicked and screamed, including some of us here, the fences became permanent. Cornell University, under the supervision of University Architect Gilbert Delgado, contracted a Boston-based architecture firm, Office dA, to design some fancy fences. Only problem is, the guy in charge of designing our fences is being evicted from his own company, which may be coming to an end soon.

Hopefully 2011 will show Cornell’s efforts to improve student mental health to have been effective.

Posted in Miscellaneous | Tagged: , | 1 Comment »

‘Suicide Fences’ Architecture Firm in Disarray over Ownership Battle

Posted by Oliver Renick on December 1, 2010

Nader Tehrani, the architect contracted by Cornell University to design suicide barriers on the school’s bridges, is in a ruthless dispute with business partner Monica Ponce de Leon over ownership of architecture firm Office dA, the Boston Globe reported today.

The co-owners of the architecture firm hired by Cornell to design bridges are burning their own. Image from GradMagazine

Cornell University hired Tehrani in late August in a $600,000 contract with Office dA to design bridge barriers as a measure to prevent student suicide on campus. Now the company Tehrani founded in 1986 is suffering from chaotic inner turmoil that may lead to the dissolution of the firm.  Only three days after Tehrani submitted the project’s pre-design proposal to the University, Ponce de Leon, the company’s majority shareholder, fired Tehrani in a move to establish herself as the firm’s owner.

“We need to regroup and figure out what our next move is,” Cornell’s University Architect Gilbert Delgado told The Cornell Review this afternoon.  “We’re trying to work through this and we’re considering our options.  This is not good news for us, but we are at a pivotal point.  We don’t have all the facts yet, we’re trying to work through them right now.”

The conflict stems from Tehrani’s agreement in 2003 to make Ponce de Leon Office dA’s majority shareholder.  As an effort to attract projects seeking female-owned firms, Tehrani handed over 51% of the company’s ownership share to his colleague of almost 20 years.  As majority shareholder, Ponce de Leon has allegedly claimed the rights to appoint new partners, make deductions from the company’s bank account, and most recently, change the building locks to prevent Tehrani from entering.

Hostility between the once romantically-involved coworkers began brewing in Dec. 2009 after Tehrani discovered Ponce de Leon had withdrawn $43,000 from the company’s account, according to The Globe.  Around the same time Tehrani was beginning design work on Cornell’s ‘means restrictive’ bridge barriers in Sept. 2010, he filed a lawsuit seeking to dissolve the firm.  Ponce de Leon has simultaneously filed suit, desiring the court to recognize her as the sole owner of Office dA. A Suffolk County Superior Court judge will begin arbitration of the lawsuits this week.

“Tehrani had informed us behind the scenes that there were some problems but he wasn’t real specific,” said Delgado.  “We didn’t think it would affect us that much, but it came to a very dramatic point to us this week.”

As Tehrani and Ponce de Leon continue to burn bridges, it is unclear how the firm’s contract with Cornell will be affected. University administrators told The Review on Wednesday that those who are responsible for overseeing the school’s contract with Tehrani will be evaluating whether or not Office dA is still the firm most capable of leading Cornell’s similarly controversial construction of permanent bridge barriers.

“We will be following this closely in the days ahead,” said Tommy Bruce, Vice President of University Communications, in an email to The Review. “It is always unfortunate to see a successful partnership come under such strains. I hope that the firm will be able to sustain the professionalism for which they are renowned.”

The bridge barrier designs have a long way to go.  Development of the pre-schematics, the different designs of the different versions, and the design of the actual final bridge barriers, still remains to be completed.  The majority of design work lies ahead, according to Delgado. The University and the city of Ithaca are scheduled to review the designs and make final decisions by a deadline of May 20, 2011.

Addition: As indicated in the comments below, Mr Tehrani has also been accused by Ponce de Leon of withdrawing $240,000 from the company account the day before she fired him.

Posted in Campus Insiders | Tagged: , , , | 6 Comments »

Preparing for Cage Life

Posted by Oliver Renick on November 30, 2010

Cornell’s campus has historically been identifiable for its rare landscape and striking natural beauty. It may soon become one that stands out by the intricate protective fences that will be constructed on nearly every campus bridge.  As part of a widely publicized and drastic overhaul of public safety measures, the University plans to install permanent barriers to resolve the year-long conflict between students and administrators on how best to prevent student suicides.

In a widely overlooked report submitted to Cornell University in early November, Office dA, the Boston-based architecture firm contracted to design the barriers, proposes options for fencing in Cornell’s most notorious bridges.  Cornell has so far spent $350,000 on temporary fencing according to The Daily Sun, and the cost will only rise as construction on the final structures is completed.

Below are some images of what the $600,000 spent by the school to hire Office dA has bought so far.  There are several different designs, and in expected Ivy League artsy fashion, none are as dull or mundane as the chain-links or black bars that have lined the walkways and roads previously. Although the fence debate is inevitably controversial, it’s proving to be immortal as well.  Deirdre Mulligan wrote a very persuasive guest article in The Sun, but that’s not to say it’s the only legitimate argument.

Seeing the proposal for these fences turns a theoretical issue into a practical one.  While many students vehemently take sides on the fence issue, the images of the fences have yet to come into the discussion.  Nagowski at MetaEzra has been the only one to publish the images so far, albeit apparently mislabeled.

Office dA has proposed hyperbolic fence shapes, cage designs, and what appear to be nets underneath some bridges.  In addition to these new structures, the firm has presented schematics for sidewalk benches and rest areas, as well as emergency phone locations along the bridges and security cameras.

Beebe dam bridge

Cascadilla Trolley Bridge

Stewart ave over Cascadilla bridge

Suspension bridge over fall creek

Posted in Campus Insiders | Tagged: , , | 4 Comments »

SA Spearheads Mental Health Campaign

Posted by Oliver Renick on November 9, 2010

The Student Assembly has announced this evening that they will take on the role of catalyst for student-to-student mental health support, launching ‘Community Caring Week,’ in which students “can relax and address mental health issues.”  The first event will take place this Thursday in Willard Straight Hall’s Memorial Room from 5:30 PM to 7:30 PM.  There will be free food, music, and activities hosted by various student groups.

Since the string of suicides that occurred last Spring, students and faculty at Cornell have desperately tried to find ways to combat depression and encourage peer assistance among the student body.  Forums, activities, and discussions have ensued to try to pull together ideas and solutions to handle issues from student anxiety to bridge fences.

In addition to providing locations where students can get together and take part in activities, the SA is proposing a resolution to the Faculty Senate that would require professors to agree that students should not be required to take or turn in 3 prelims or papers within a 4 day period.

With hopes that it will relieve student stress, the resolution would be the first to make a concrete reorganization of Cornell’s academic schedule.  Roneal Desai ’13, presenter of the resolution, hopes some measures will go into effect as early as next semester, with full implementation of the plan by Fall 2011.

“For students, there’s no secret that a large amount of our stress is derived from our work in the classroom,” Desai told the Review. “It seems silly not to cut down on student stress as much as possible to prevent these cases from occurring.”

From the S.A.’s blog:

Sadly, we can’t all take the preparation required to tackle depression in individual students by ourselves, but we all have the capability to express to professors simpler things they can do that make our lives less stressful–specifically, cutting down on “hell weeks” as much as possible.

As of the now, the exam limitations will only take place during the regular school year, not during exam week.  In addition to the test limitations, Desai hopes to “have make-up tests be spaced further away from original tests, and for professors to learn student’s names. We hope that students will realize the importance of these discussions with professors and will volunteer their time to join on to the cause and try and make a sizable difference.”

The Student Assembly is encouraging Cornellians to take part by helping out during the Community Caring events, providing a sign-up sheet for students to fill out before getting involved.

Posted in Campus Insiders | Tagged: , , , | 2 Comments »

MRM #70

Posted by Cornell Insider Staff on October 11, 2010

- SDT (originally founded at Cornell) moves onto the UVA grounds.

- More misconstrued information: “It’s the same idea behind the barriers that have gone up on the bridges over the gorges in Ithaca, New York, where six Cornell University students committed suicide last year.”

- “As part of Lehigh’s efforts to illustrate the true effects of hazing during National Hazing Prevention Week, Travis Apgar, associate dean of students at Cornell University, spoke Tuesday about his own traumatizing hazing experiences during his college years.” Hmm.

- Missing Ithaca girl found.

- Cornell loses appeal in worker death compensation case.

- The smoking ban in the Ithaca Commons has been expanded.

- Cornell is a gift of “big government,” apparently.

- Two Cornellians make the Forbes list of most powerful women in the world.

- New book, Asians in the Ivory Tower.

- Football falls to 1-3 after a loss to Harvard.

- Planning to vote in November? Didn’t think so.

Posted in Campus Insiders, National News | Tagged: , , , , | Leave a Comment »

MRM #65

Posted by Cornell Insider Staff on September 5, 2010

- Collegetown residents: lock your doors.

- Developing plans for permanent fences.

- Via MR, 9 evidence-based study tips. They’re common sense but frequently neglected.

- In case you missed it, here’s our lead editorial from the first issue.

- Cornell researchers will try to improve farming in Africa with a new grant.

- More trouble for the former Green Cafe owner. More here.

- Ithaca suicide prevention walk scheduled for September 19.

- Dump truck rolls over near Commons.

- Why students are attracted to the Ivy League.

- The issues in the Mosque debate.

- Universities add gold to their investment portfolios.

Posted in Campus Insiders, National News | Tagged: , , , , | Leave a Comment »

Fences To Stay Put Until May 31, 2011.

Posted by Cornell Insider Staff on July 23, 2010

The “permanent solution” to Cornell’s bridge suicide problem is unlikely to be implemented until the end of the the 2010-2011 academic year. While the full Common Council will not vote on the matter until August 4, it’s likely that they will follow the unanimous vote of the CC planning committee. So if everything goes as expected, you can plan on seeing these new, more aesthetically pleasing bridge barriers through Spring finals.

Posted in Campus Insiders | Tagged: , , | Leave a Comment »

MRM #58

Posted by Cornell Insider Staff on July 18, 2010

- Great article from the Sens on Colin Greening’s progress at their rookie development camp.

- Cornell’s suicide rate over the past 21 years is below the national average.

- Sticking around Ithaca for the summer? Don’t miss the world series of weeds.

- Former Cornell Lax standout Max Seibald dominates at the Lacrosse World Championships.

- The fire that destroyed an Ithaca police officer’s home has been ruled an arson. More here.

- Ithaca plans to proceed with a door-to-door dog count.

- Stanford Review alumnus and blogger Paul Craft takes a look at the Class of 2010′s job market.

- Via MetaEzra, great video of the 161 list.

- Want to be a CEO? Major in Econ.

- Going abroad isn’t useless, new study finds.

- Behavioral economics-motivated policies are only band-aid solutions for larger economic problems. (HT Nate Schorr)

Posted in Campus Insiders, National News | Tagged: , , , , | Leave a Comment »

Details On Prevented Gorge Suicide

Posted by Cornell Insider Staff on June 7, 2010

The Ithaca Journal has a detailed account of the prevented gorge suicide on May 24. The article attributes the successful rescue of the 31 year old man to quick thinking by an unidentified woman– who was already speaking to the man before police arrived– as well as the police officers who convinced the man to secure himself with a rope before they cut through the fence and took him to safety. But perhaps the most shocking detail of this story is how the man managed to negotiate the fence. Everyone has pointed out the weak points of the North Campus and Collegetown bridges where people can easily come around the fence and climb up onto the bridge, but apparently the fences themselves don’t serve as great barriers:

At 3:37 p.m. May 24, Ithaca and Cornell police officers responded to the Stewart Avenue Bridge and found a man sitting on the west railing, outside of the fence near the bridge’s north end, according to police reports. The fence and others were installed on gorge bridges in Ithaca this winter after suicides off bridges by students, but according to the reports, two witnesses said they saw the man “scale the fence, go over the top of the cables, and sit in the area where he was located by responding personnel.”

Unlike Oliver, I haven’t been an outspoken opponent of the fences. I’ve always argued that the administration had no choice to put them up, and I think there is evidence that these kinds of barriers can help prevent impulsive suicides. But I maintain that this incident– and in particular the manner in which the man negotiated the fence– might just be the straw that breaks the camel’s back. I just don’t see how Cornell will be able to make a good case for these fences before the Common Council after the new 10-week extension is up, given the reluctance with which some members voted to approve the extension this time around.

Posted in Campus Insiders | Tagged: , , | Leave a Comment »

Top Blogosphere Stories of 2009-2010

Posted by Cornell Insider Staff on June 5, 2010

In the most recent issue of the Review we had a story on the Top 10 Cornell News Stories of 2009-2010. As we finish yet another semester at Cornell, we look back at the top stories covered on the Cornell Insider in 2009-2010.

Sweet 16 Basketball Run: While the Penn Quakers managed to tarnish what would have been a perfect Ivy League season for the Red, this didn’t stop us from taking a third consecutive Ivy League Championship . The men ’s basketball team’s success continued at the national level, where the team secured two huge victories over Temple and Wisconsin (Obama predicted the first, but not the second). The excitement was building all the way up to our Sweet Sixteen Matchup, where the Big Red ended up losing at the hands of the all-NBA first ranked Kentucky Wildcats. It was the most successful Ivy League team run since 1979. But all good things come to pass: Steve Donahue left for BC shortly after the season ended. Enter Bill Courtney. Can he lead the Red to another Ivy League Championship? 2011 will tell.

Spring Suicides: It all began on February 17 when we reported an apparent suicide off Thurston Bridge. By the evening, the body was confirmed to be that of Bradley Ginsburg ’13. Less than a month later we were shocked to hear the news of yet another gorge suicide– this time the victim was William Sinclair ’12. Photos of policemen and rescue workers, taken by Review Managing Editor Lucas Policastro at the scene, are lucid reminders of the eerie and tragic mood that descended on campus that day. Twenty four hours later, yet another suicide was reported, this time off of the Suspension bridge. I remember most of my friends were in disbelief: there’s no way, how could there be another suicide the next day and the third in less than a month? The death of Matthew Zika ’11 shifted Cornell into suicide lockdown mode. Guards were placed at every university bridge for the following week.  When the guards left, the fences were erected. The crisis brought national attention to Cornell’s campus and also raised questions about levels of stress and competition at the university. Almost three months later, despite much debate and controversy, the fences remain as a reminder that we still have no permanent solution to the Cornell suicide problem.

Resolution 44: Much was made across the campus about Resolution 44, the so-called “non-discrimination clause,” introduced in the Student Assembly by Andrew Brockman ’ 11 and Matt Danzer ’12. Among other things, the clause would have banned clubs from removing an officer or preventing someone from becoming an officer based on a conflict of beliefs. This resolution polarized the Cornell community as it was met with both steadfast support and outspoken opposition. Many believed that his endorsement of Resolution 44 cost Brokman his bid for the SA Presidency (including his opponent, Vincent Andrews). It didn’t come as much of a surprise to Review writers when Skorton did not end up signing Resolution 44.

Reimagining Cornell: While this story received a lot more attention in our paper edition, it’s too important to skip over here. The financial crisis of 2008 made a significant dent in Cornell’s endowment, prompting an initiative to cut costs and restructure the budgets, faculties, and operations of all seven colleges. The newest version of the strategic plan, entitled “Cornell University at Its Sesquicentennial,” aims to move past the crisis and return Cornell to its place in the top ten research universities in the country. But what will this mean for the undergraduate colleges? Will the Cornell of ten years from now even resemble the Cornell of today? This story remains unfinished, and will likely be among our list of top stories for 2010-2011 as well.

Swine Flu: Right at the beginning of the academic year, with swine flu hysteria at its peak nationwide, Cornell endured its own outbreak of the disease. By the time the epidemic had subsided in the late fall, thousands had become ill, and, sadly, one student (Warren Schorr ’11) was lost to complications of the illness. The university’s response was rapid and diverse. Gannett offered shots for the disease as soon as they became available for mass use, and hand sanitizers were set up and distributed throughout campus. Every student received a multitude of emails discussing preventative measures, and signs were set up in public places to encourage care. While the necessity of some of these measures was debated, many of them were also credited for ending the outbreak in the late fall/early winter.

Program House Debate: Perhaps this story was overshadowed by other Cornell-related stories in the spring, or maybe its controversy was exaggerated to begin with, but the program house debate certainly lost a lot of steam going into the second half of the year. But a small recap for our readers (adpated largely from our December Top Stories List) is in order. It all started with the announcement that program houses would be put under review, which instantly sparked a symbolic funeral march for the death of program houses in early April (followed by Review commentary). Over the summer, there was the Ken Glover debacle/reassignment, then the re-reassignement, which was followed by another reinstatement (followed by more Reviewcommentary). Then there was the Program House panel, which was followed by even more Cornell Review commentary and input. In the end, more than a year later, nothing has changed. Program Houses are still here to stay, just as Vice President for Student and Academic Services Susan Murphy ’73 told Review reporters after the initial protest in April 2009.

Posted in Campus Insiders, National News | Tagged: , , | 1 Comment »

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: